Homes on the 4x4 beaches north of Corolla, where the Colonial Spanish Mustangs walk past the porch. Four-wheel drive required.
Every home here is in the 4WD-only stretch, and every listing says so. Not a ranking.

North of the paved road in Corolla the beach becomes the highway. Eleven miles of it, no pavement, and a herd of wild horses descended from Spanish stock that has lived there for centuries. You need a four-wheel-drive vehicle to reach the house, and the listing will tell you that before it tells you about the pool.
Eight homes from three managers who work the 4x4 beaches. Each card quotes what the listing says about access and the horses. Each links to the manager; you book with them.
Preview from Brindley Beach Vacations's listingThe horses are protected. Stay 50 feet back, never feed them, and drive the beach the way the county asks. The fund that looks after the herd is the right place to learn the rules.