Ocracoke, where Blackbeard died in 1718. Homes a walk from Springer's Point and the water they call Teach's Hole.
Ocracoke only, and the page says why. Every listing names Springer's Point. Not a ranking.

Edward Teach was killed in the water off Ocracoke in November 1718, in a channel the island still calls Teach's Hole. He had been anchored there. The live oak woods above the shore, Springer's Point, is where the story ends, and it is a nature preserve now that you can walk into from the village.
Five homes, all from Ocracoke Island Realty, all a walk from Springer's Point per their listings. Here is the honest part: managers on this coast almost never write the word Blackbeard on a listing. They write Springer's Point, and that is the same place. When a manager on Hatteras or in Beaufort writes the history into a listing, they go on this page.
Managers on Hatteras and the Crystal Coast write Blackbeard into their blogs, not their listings, so their homes are not here. Beaufort's maritime museum holds the artifacts from the wreck believed to be Queen Anne's Revenge.