Homes whose listings name the light: Currituck, Bodie Island, Cape Hatteras, Ocracoke. Four lighthouses, four ends of the beach.
Every listing here names a lighthouse. Roanoke Marshes is covered on the history page. Not a ranking.

Five lights guard a hundred miles of barrier island, and each one has a town around it. Currituck's red brick at the top in Corolla. Bodie Island's stripes south of Nags Head. Cape Hatteras, the tallest in the country, moved half a mile inland in 1999 and still standing. Ocracoke's white tower at the end of the ferry.
Eight homes from five managers, every listing naming its lighthouse. Each links to the manager; you book with them.
Preview from Resort Realty's listing
Preview from Resort Realty's listingCurrituck and Bodie Island climb seasonally; Cape Hatteras climbing depends on restoration status; Ocracoke does not climb. Check before you promise the kids.